Showing posts with label code of good conduct. Show all posts
Showing posts with label code of good conduct. Show all posts

Monday, 6 October 2014

Dealer Protection Code - Dead in the Water

The much-vaunted code of conduct to which the Commission encouraged the two sides of the industry to agree after removing the dealer protection measures from the 2010 block exemption, has finally been knocked on the head by ACEA. Auto Retail Network reports the Association’s Legal Director Marc Greven, stating at CECRA’s European Car Dealer Conference in Brussels in late September that the organisation did not plan to agree to a code.
That is not to say that there will never be a code, just that ACEA does not consider that its job includes agreeing one. Mr Greven said it was a contractual matter between manufacturers and their dealers. But if that is the case, what was the draft code promulgated by ACEA JAMA supposed to be for? CECRA never liked that much, and of course the manufacturers never liked the dealers’ proposals either. Has the ACEA/JAMA code also been dropped?
The Commission announced last December that if the two sides did not agree, it would impose a solution, and it set the end of this year as a deadline – coinciding with the conclusion of work on the CARS 2020 Project (see Motor Law, volume 13 number 11 and this posting). That looked encouraging, for those who like the idea of a code, but it appears that it failed to take into account that the Commission was up for a replacement in the interim, and as we are seeing now new Commissioners are being appointed as the old ones make their exits. Commissioner Almumia’s parting speech is reported elsewhere in this issue. So along the line, the Commission’s commitment went from a statement of intent to see this through, to reserving the right to introduce legislation on unfair trading practices. Since when, incidentally, did the Commission have to reserve the right to do something within its powers?
Carlo Pettinelli, currently Director of Industrial Innovation and Mobility Industries in DG Enterprise & Industry, did however assure the CECRA Conference that the subject was still firmly in the minds of the people responsible. So action before the year end can still be expected.

Monday, 26 May 2014

Commission rejects Federauto's complaint against VW

The European Commission has rejected a complain lodged by the Italian dealer organisation, Federauto, concerning SEAT dealer agreements. The complaint alleged that competition rules had been broken because teh manufacturer (Volkswagen Group Italia) had unilaterally reduced the dealers' margin from 15.85 per cent to 12.85 per cent, and had converted part of the margin from fixed to variable. The case is number AT.40050: it is not easy to find on the Commission website (a Google search found it for me) and anyway it is 10 pages of Italian, which might be more useful to you than it is to me. It is however helpfully reported by our good friends at Van Bael and Bellis: here is a link to the article on the Mondaq service, for which you might have to register. It is also in that firm's competition law newsletter, the relevant edition of which you can download from here.
Federauto argued that this violated the rationale underlying Art 3 of Regulation 1400 as well as being contrary to the vertical restraints block exemption regulation (Regulation 330/2010). Not a great start to be basing your case on the law's rationale rather than its clear words, and always a bad idea to rely on positive obligations created by a block exemption, because generally there aren't any. If you read the argument as being that because of the failure to comply with the conditions for exemption set out in the Regulation(s) the agreement was in breach of Article 101 of the Treaty, that sounds a bit better: but it still doesn't get you to where you want to be, because you then have to convince the Commission that there is a breach Article 101 somewhere.
The Commission was not convinced. There was no evidence of a restriction of competition, such as would breach Article 101(1). The clauses in the dealership contracts concerning margins were not hardcore restrictions. The new margins did not amount to retail price maintenance because dealers remained free to fund their own discounts on sales to consumers.
The complaint also touched on another, very sensitive, area: Federauto complained that VWGI did not have a code of conduct regulating relationships with dealers. The Commission's Supplemental Guidelines on Vertical Restraints in Agreements for the Sale and Repair of Motor Vehicles tells us, of course, that the existence of such a code is a relevant factor in assessing a supplier's conduct in individual cases concerning pressure on dealers to achieve anti-competitive outcomes. However, there was no evidence that such pressure had been exerted and the Commission stated that mere failure to have a code did not amount to a breach. Nothing very surprising there.
The complaint could be seen as a last-ditch attempt to restore dealer protection principles to the block exemption regime, following their removal in the latest iteration of the Regulation. If that is what it was, the best that can be said is "nice try". Dealer protection is never going to be restored by asking the Commission to read something into the Regulation that clearly isn't there: it is going to come from the Commission imposing a code of conduct on the manufacturers, or adopting legislation like the commercial agents' directive.

Monday, 25 July 2011

Selling franchised dealerships

One of the important pieces of protection given to dealers in the 2002 Block Exemption - still there, until 2013, but cut from the new version of the Regulation - is the right to transfer the franchise to another member of the network. Previously, vehicle manufacturers had generally reserved the right to dictate to whom a dealer might sell, and often they would have preferred candidates. "Of course you can sell your dealership: and this is who you can sell it to ...". The provision in the 2002 Regulation that effectively said members of the network were pre-approved recognised an inherent truth in the way dealer networks are structured, but at the same time deprived manufacturers of protection against over-concentration of franchises in the hands of large dealer groups, which can be as much a problem for competition as vehicle manufacturers having market power.

With the removal of this condition for exemption, the protection of dealers will be significantly weakened. Whether this is a good or bad thing depends in the first place on where you stand - but to my mind, this is a dealer protection provision too far. No-one should be obliged to do business with someone they haven't chosen. Competition law does not generally require this, although for a dominant firm a refusal to supply may be an abuse (and therefore a breach of Article 102 TFEU or Part II of the Competition Act). Within the manufacturer-dealer relationship, of course, the manufacturer might be regarded as dominant, and certainly just because the new Regulation is silent on the question of transfers doesn't mean that the manufacturer will always be able to impose its wishes on the dealer - there is no exemption from Article 102.

However, the biggest limitation on the usefulness of the block exemption has always been the gap between the rights given to dealers and the practicalities of enforcing them. Legal action against a vehicle manufacturer to enforce rights given by the Regulation has clearly never been an attractive proposition for dealers: I can't think of any legal actions being brought. There have been a few disputes referred to expert determination, as the Regulation also requires for certain matters, but not many. Even just intimating to one's supplier that one's rights might have been breached is likely to be a step too far for most dealers.

The removal of the automatic right to transfer will look to dealers like a huge step backwards. On the face of it, manufacturers will be able arbitrarily to stop dealers transferring their business as a going concern. In fact, it merely reinforces the fact that the value of that business is built entirely on a contract, and it is common to find that rights under a commercial contract cannot be transferred freely. Obligations perhaps, but that makes no difference here. And even now, if the manufacturer doesn't like what the dealer proposes to do it can terminate the contract on notice. It would have to state its reasons, which must be objective, but unless it were blatantly anti-competitive it's not likely to help the dealer much as the block exemption contains no automatic sanction for a breach of this requirement. So perhaps the current dealer protection measure doesn't count for much anyway.

So there's a window of opportunity until the end of May 2013 for dealers to sell or buy, if they see an opportunity for consolidation - and manufacturers will probably be cautious about trying to terminate in such circumstances. (Of course, many networks are under wholesale  notices of termination during the two-year run-up to the change anyway.) After that, the basic competition rules will be there as a long-stop to prevent egregious anti-competitive behaviour - as they always have been. And there remains the possibility that the matter will be dealt with in the much-vaunted Code of Conduct.

However, the Code of good practice regarding certain aspects of vertical agreements in the motor vehicle sector. seems to be in trouble. The manufacturers, through ACEA, had offered a draft, but it didn't cover all the aspects of dealer protection - being limited to dispute resolution and minimum periods of notice. The Commission, which at first adopted a "hands off" approach consistent with its view that dealer protection had nothing to do with competition, has now become more proactive and announced that it wanted ACEA to reach agreement with CECRA before November this year. Subsequently it seems that ACEA has decided not to take part in further discussions - presumably, standing by its draft Code. So whether we will ever see anything in a form useful to dealers is up in the air - but as ACEA will be well aware there's always the general competition law lurking in the background to deal with any arbitrary exercise of power by vehicle manufacturers - if dealers dare invoke it.